Progressive Policy Institute



The Institute

New from PPI

Memos to the New President

2008 Briefing Series

Events

Press Center

Press Releases Op-Eds About Us Headlines Issues
National Defense & Homeland Security

Foreign Policy

Economic & Fiscal Policy

Trade & Global Markets

Energy & Environment

Health Care

Technology & Innovation

The New Economy

Work, Family & Community

National Service & Civic Enterprise

Quality of Life

Crime & Public Safety

Political Reform

Education


The Third Way



All_Our_Might.com

About PPIContact UsPress Centerspacer

Press Center
Press Releases

PPI | Press Release | March 15, 2001
PPI Warns of 'Digital Iron Curtain' Unless International E-Commerce Issues are Addressed
For Immediate Release
Contact:
Matthew Frankel / Katharine Lister -- (202) 547-0001


Note: Senator Joseph Lieberman and Representative Ellen Tauscher sent letters to the President, U.S. Trade Representative Robert Zoellick, and their Congressional colleagues in support of PPI's "A Third Way Framework for Global E-Commerce" report.


Washington, D.C. -- The Progressive Policy Institute (PPI) warned today that regulatory uncertainty could threaten the viability of international e-commerce and proposed a policy framework to alleviate global conflicts which threaten free trade on the Internet.

As the Internet expands globally, the cross-border nature of the technology is revolutionizing international trade. Consumers now have the ability to bypass the traditional export-import system and conduct a transaction directly with a foreign seller, without needing to travel to the seller's country. But unless industry and policy makers can come to grips with a host of pressing policy issues, web consumers may lose confidence to visit web sites beyond their national borders and with the mish-mash of confusing and conflicting laws of nearly 200 nations, many erected by countries seeking to protect their domestic industries from global e-commerce competitors, e-commerce sellers may find it easier to not conduct business with foreign buyers. The PPI paper, entitled "A Third Way Framework for Global E-Commerce," by Robert Atkinson, Director of the Technology and New Economy Project at PPI, and Shane Ham, Technology Policy Analyst for the Technology and New Economy Project, lays out a comprehensive policy framework and proposes specific policy recommendations to ensure that this emerging form of trade is allowed to flourish.

"The Internet is revolutionizing trade by connecting sellers and buyers in different countries directly," Atkinson said. "But if consumers are wary of venturing into foreign cyberspaces or businesses are burdened by conflicting national laws, we risk the creation of a digital iron curtain which may balkanize the Internet, causing the World Wide Web to become Numerous National Nets."

To preserve the cross-border nature of the Internet and promote its continued growth, policymakers must address two essential questions: jurisdiction, the question of whose laws apply to a cross-border transaction; and sovereignty, the question of how much domestic control over access to the global Internet must be relinquished in order to promote global e-commerce. Through a combination of government action and development of new private institutions, it is possible to create an environment of trust for buyers and sellers that will allow cross-border electronic commerce to flourish. PPI has developed a framework of six principles to achieve this goal:

  • Take a cautious approach to regulation: allow global e-commerce time to develop before determining which areas will require government action.
    In order to realize fully the benefit of global e-commerce, governments must lend a helping hand where necessary to reduce the risks of cross border transactions, but cross-border e- commerce must develop further before it can be determined when and where government action can be used effectively.

  • Increase global market access: maximize opportunities for buyers and sellers to come together.
    Empowering consumers and sellers -- especially small enterprises -- by expanding market access should be the main goal of any government action (or forbearance of action) regarding global e-commerce.

  • Don't use regulations for protectionism: signatories to the WTO or other multilateral trade agreements should not be allowed to impose rules on e-commerce or the Internet with the intent of reducing online foreign competition.
    Rather than try to create rules and regulations to limit global e-commerce, nations would be better off pursuing policies designed to build a robust digital domestic economy (e.g. telecommunications reform, including flat-rate call pricing for Internet access; digital government; deregulation; and technology investment).

  • Enforce regulations domestically: governments cannot impose their laws on foreign companies unless those companies target their activities within the government's territory or a treaty is in effect.
    A government cannot "reach out" and exercise authority in another country, but it can exercise authority if someone in another country "reaches in" to consumers in its jurisdiction.

  • Limit restrictions on social, cultural, and political content: government restrictions on content cannot block trade in violation of WTO principles and must be enforced only within the restricting government's territory.
    If governments choose to exercise control over the foreign Internet content that their citizens may access, every nation must demand that every other nation adhere to two conditions: such controls must apply only to cultural, social, and political content, not trade and all content controls must be implemented domestically.

  • Take advantage of technology: encourage innovation in the development of technological tools and industry best practices that solve public policy problems.
    Consumer-empowering technology, when fully implemented, may help alleviate the desire for strict government controls on data privacy practices and facilitate easier negotiation between nations with different privacy regimes.

    This report may represent the first overarching, logically consistent policy framework for international e-commerce in the 21st century. As nations begin to debate in the international arena a whole host of issues -- consumer protection, data privacy, taxation, content regulation, copyright, spam, jurisdiction, customs duties, import and export restrictions, cyber crime, and more -- following the framework's principles will ensure that the world wide web will remain truly global.


    Letter from Sen. Lieberman & Rep. Tauscher to the President

    Letter from Sen. Lieberman & Rep. Tauscher to U.S. Trade Representative Robert Zoellick

    Letter from Sen. Lieberman & Rep. Tauscher to their Congressional colleagues








  • Search Tips 

    Support PPI
    Make an online gift
    Get Email Updates
    Learn More  

    Print Printable Version of this Article

    Send this Article to a FriendSend this Article to a Friend

    File Attachments Letter_to_TradeRep.pdf

    Letter_to_President.pdf

    Letter_to_Congress.pdf


    Related Links A Third Way Framework for Global E-Commerce

    Privacy Statementndol_ci.cfm?contentid=250168&kaid=106&subid=122Email GroupsJobsInternshipsSupportOur Publications

    Site designed and managed by Beaconfire Consulting