PPI | Briefing | June 23, 1995
Second Chance Homes Breaking the Cycle of Teen Pregnancy By Kathleen Sylvester
The full text of this report is available in Adobe PDF format. Click
"Full_Report.pdf" under the red File Attachments header on the right.
For many Americans, teenage welfare mothers symbolize the
tragedy of our nation's failed welfare policy and the
unraveling of our nation's social fabric. Growing numbers of
poor and uneducated young women, often still children
themselves, are using public support to bear and raise
children outside of marriage. These young women are not only
a reminder of government's inability to address a
fundamental social problem, but more importantly, they are
producing a new generation of poor and fatherless children
who will begin life with disadvantages from which they may
never recover.
The current public debate over teen mothers offers
Congress and the nation an opportunity to break the cycle
and move beyond the punitive solutions proposed by
conservatives and the defense of a failed welfare system
offered by liberals.
The Progressive Policy Institute (PPI) offers an
alternative that invokes society's values, requires
responsibility and reciprocity from welfare recipients, and
engages communities in solving the problem.
PPI's proposal would create a national network of
"second-chance homes" group residences in which teen mothers
whose own homes are unstable or unsafe, live under adult
supervision with their children, while meeting their social
and personal obligations for receiving welfare support.
These homes, with seed money and guidance from the federal
government, would bring together in one setting the three
fundamental elements teen mothers need if they are to have a
chance to succeed: socialization, nurturing and support, and
structure and discipline.
Getting Started: How the Policy Would Work. Second-chance
homes offer a unique opportunity for a partnership among
teen mothers, government, and communities: Under PPI's
proposal:
Participants would use portions of their welfare and
foster care payments and federal nutrition and housing
subsidies, as program fees to offset the costs of the
homes.
Government would provide seed money, guidance, and
evaluation, acting as a catalyst for community action.
The federal government would set aside $20 million a
year for three years to create a national network of
second-chance homes.
Communities, too, must, join the effort. Tens of
thousands of "community" members from neighborhood
clinics, women's groups, Rotary Clubs, fraternal
organizations, senior citizens' groups, and youth
groups would join government and supply the element now
missing in attempts to help teen mothers and their
children: a connection to the communities and their
values.
A Limited Experiment. PPI initially proposes second-chance
homes serve teen mothers under the age of 18 for three
reasons. First, teen mothers under age 18 are the most
likely of any welfare recipients to become long-term
recipients of welfare. In fact, nearly half of long-term
recipients are women who give birth before the age of 17.
Second, the requirement for many teen mothers to live
in such homes sends a strong message to young females:
Society no longer offers unconditional, open-ended financial
support for teens who bear children out of wedlock.
Government will help, but only if they meet mutual
obligations: learning to be good parents, finishing school,
and joining the workforce.
Third, mothers under age 18 represent only a small
percentage of unwed teen mothers. In 1993, the U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services reported that there
were nearly 296,000 unmarried teen mothers on welfare,
67,000 of whom were under age 18. Not only are these mothers
in need of the most help, but their small number represents
a manageable start for communities ready to get involved.
Elements of a Successful Home. Across the country,
successful prototypes for second-chance homes already exist.
These homes respond to the reality of teen mothers' lives.
Their designs incorporate all three elements necessary to
offer them a chance to succeed: socialization, nurturing and
support, and structure and discipline. They create a sense
of order; help girls grow up to be women; require and
support education and job training; provide health care,
mentors, protection from abusive men, and a sense of family
and belonging.
How do we Measure Success? PPI does not propose these homes
as a guaranteed solution to the problem of teen pregnancy,
but rather as a promising idea. The prototypes for these
homes scattered across the country have produced some
notable results: fewer second pregnancies, dramatically
increased school completion rates for mothers, reduced
incidence of child abuse, better maternal and child health,
increased placement for adoption, higher employment rates,
and reduced welfare dependency.
The idea is worth trying. If we cannot find a way to
help teen mothers, their children will pay the price. The
problem is urgent. There are now nine million children
living in welfare families. As those nine million children
reach adolescence, many are "scripted" to repeat the lives
of their parents. We must intervene and break the cycle
before those children, too, become a new generation of
disadvantage.
Examples of residential treatment centers for pregnant teens
exist in a number of states. These facilities can be small
or large; they are usually funded by varying combinations of
private and public monies. Some are located in inner cities,
others in more rural areas.
Some have large professional staffs, others are staffed
mainly by volunteers. Most accept teen mothers between the
ages of 15 and 18 and limit their stay to about two years.
The majority accept only teens who already have children,
although a handful accept pregnant teens. Some programs must
accept mothers assigned to them by the courts or social
service agencies; others simply accept all of the applicants
or referrals they can accommodate. All programs require
participants to be enrolled in school or job training. In
general, services include classes in parenting and life
skills as well as some counseling and support services. Day
care is an important component of these programs, though not
always provided on-site. Vocational training and job
placement services are sometimes available.
Alamogordo United Futures
1815 N. Florida Avenue
Alamogordo, NM 88310
Mobile Telephone: (505) 430-8897
For more information contact: Richard Brandner, Director
The Group Home serves both low-income elderly women capable
of living independently and young women with their children.
Family stability and intergenerational experience are
encouraged. The 12-unit facility housing the United Futures
Project is owned by Northwest Association for Retarded
Citizens and mortgaged under HUD Section 202 funding for
facilities for special needs populations.
Various services are provided to both the elderly women
and the teenage mothers. Services available to seniors
include transportation to the Alamo Senior Center, legal
services, health promotion, and recreation at the Senior
Center. Young mothers are provided child care assistance,
assistance in enhancing life and parenting skills, and
financial assistance for school. The state spends $25,000 to
pay a portion of the director's salary; teen mothers are
eligible for low-income rent subsidies; they pay their rent
from their welfare checks.
Amity Street, Transitional Housing for Parenting Teens
Catholic Charities, North Region
55 Lynn Shore Drive
Lynn, MA 01902
(617) 593-2312
For more information contact: Richard D. Muzzy, Director of
Outreach and Youth Services
Amity Street consists of a nine-unit building that houses
young single mothers ages 18-23 with one or two children
under the age of five. The home opened in October 1987, and
has served a total of 42 young mothers and 55 children. They
are able to maintain their own residences with the support
of Catholic Charities' staff for up to two years. The
program offers counseling, case management, support groups,
and assistance with employment training and education.
The program costs approximately $190,000 per year. Some
funding for support services is received through the
Department of Social Services. Residents are eligible for
rent subsidies through the Massachusetts Rental Voucher
Program administered by the Lynn Housing Authority. United
Way and local fundraising efforts further maintain the
program.
Bridgeway
85 S. Union Boulevard - Suite 204
Lakewood, CO 80228
(303) 969-0515
For more information contact: Rich Haas, Executive Director
Founded in 1986, Bridgeway is a private, nonprofit
organization that operates three homes and an education
center for 16 pregnant teenagers and their babies. Parenting
mothers can stay up to six months or more in a home
supervised by live-in houseparents. Bridgeway has an annual
budget of approximately $235,000 and is funded by workplace
campaigns and business and individual donations.
Bridgeway provides counseling and classes in Lamaze
childbirth, self-esteem, nutrition, parenting, adoption
options, prenatal care, resume-writing, job skills, and drug
abuse. Volunteers from the community serve as "Bridgers" who
act as mentors.
Door of Hope
2799 Health Center Drive
San Diego, CA 92123
(619) 279-1100
For more information contact: Charlie Cox, Director
Door of Hope consists of two homes: one for pregnant
teenagers, and one called Havens for young women with
emotional and psychological problems. The maternity home
serves approximately 50 residents per year, and Havens takes
in an average of 25 young women per year. The women are
admitted only if they are wards of the court or are legally
emancipated from their guardians.
Door of Hope offers 24-hour supervision by residential
managers, an on-campus public school, counseling, prenatal
care, day care, and classes in independent living skills,
parenting, alcohol and drug abuse, Lamaze childbirth, job
placement, and discharge planning. There are 40 paid staff
members in addition to volunteer support.
The cost of the program per girl for the maternity home
is $2,360 per month, and for Havens it is $4,423 per month.
The babies cost about $708 per month in both homes. Havens
costs more because the young women placed there have fairly
severe emotional, psychological, or behavioral problems and
need more specialized care.
Father Pat Jackson House Program
1014 South Main Street
Ann Arbor, MI 48104
(313) 761-1440
For more information contact: LaTresa Wiley
Father Pat's is a transitional home that houses five teenage
mothers and their babies. Residents can stay for up to two
years, but the average stay is four to six months. The house
is staffed by a director, social worker, two house mothers,
and two overnight staff. Volunteers are generally University
of Michigan students who provide transportation and
mentoring.
Due to Father Pat's affiliation with St. Mary's Parish,
funding comes mostly from grants in the Catholic community
and from private grants. The cost of the program is $260 a
month per mother and baby, which is $15,600 a year for the
total program.
Florence Crittenton Homes and Services of West Virginia
2606 National Road
Wheeling, WV 26003-5393
(304) 242-7060
For more information contact: Sharon Perry, Executive Secretary
FCHS of West Virginia was created in 1895 as a residential
home for young mothers. In the 1991-92 program year it
served more than 1,100 young mothers throughout West
Virginia and Belmont County, Ohio. Pregnant teenagers are
referred from the Department of Health and Human Resources,
the judicial system, high school counselors, church leaders,
and family members.
Located in a residential neighborhood, the facility is
equipped with an alternative on-site school, a day care
center, a health clinic, and counseling and case management
services. The main facility is surrounded by three
residential homes that are used for transitional living
programs and is staffed full-time.
Crittenton also offers 10 community, home-based service
sites. Programs here include maternity care, community
outreach, pregnancy and child abuse prevention programs, day
care, health clinics, support groups, Lamaze childbirth,
child care, parent skills training, adoption and adoption
counseling, family and group counseling, life skills
training, case management, and family preservation services.
FCHS is funded by foundations, corporations, private
donations, and client fees.
Homes for the Homeless
36 Cooper Square, 6th Floor
New York, NY 10003
(212) 529-5252
For more information, contact: Page Bartels, Director of Development and External Affairs
Founded in 1986, Homes for the Homeless is a comprehensive,
residential nonprofit organization that has served 8,400
families including more than 18,300 children in New York
City. The cost of the program is $12,000 per person
annually, or $36,000 per family annually. Homes for the
Homeless also operates two summer camps for homeless
children.
Homes for the Homeless operates four "American Family
Inns," which offer housing and comprehensive services to
homeless mothers and their children. A needs assessment is
developed for each family upon entry to the centers.
Assistance is offered in the areas of health care,
educational enhancement for both parents and children,
employment training, foster care, independent living skills,
substance abuse treatment, and follow-up services. Two
innovative aspects of the program are a "safe nursery" for
children at risk of abuse and an in-house apprenticeship
program, where residents learn job skills by working within
the organization.
Northwest Maternity Center
4010 12th Street, N.E.
Washington, DC 20017
(202) 483-7008
For more information contact: Elizabeth Segal
The Northwest Maternity Center is a private/nonprofit
residential facility for five mothers with one or two
children, which operates in tandem with the Pregnancy
Center. The center has been open for two years, and 26 young
women have completed the program. The two facilities exist
on a shoestring budget of $160,000 a year, with the
Maternity Center getting about $60,000 of that amount.
Funding comes from private individuals and corporate donors
and includes donations of food, toys, and furniture.
The center has flexible admission and length of stay
requirements. The mothers are between the ages of 15 and 24,
and stay less than two years. They are referred from
community agencies, schools, and the Pregnancy Center.
The only paid staff members are the director and the
social services director, so the home depends heavily on a
volunteer staff of 18. The program includes counseling,
referrals, and classes in parenting, child development,
basic skills, and self-esteem.
Seton Home
1115 Mission Road
San Antonio, TX 78210
(210) 533-3504
For more information contact: Brenda Tatro, Executive Director
Licensed by the state of Texas, Seton Home is a group home
for pregnant teenagers and teenage mothers, aged 12-20. The
facility consists of two cottages, each of which houses
eight mothers and their babies. Approximately 35 mothers go
through the program each year.
Each cottage is staffed by one house mother or
independent living skills instructor. In addition, Seton
Home has a social service director, volunteer coordinator,
and an executive director. Volunteers perform such tasks as
office work, yard work, and mother's day out activities.
Seton Home has an annual budget of $330,000. The United
Way provides 20 percent of the funding, while the remainder
comes from grants, fundraising projects, direct mail
campaigns, and support for money for some mothers from the
state.
St. Ann's Infant and Mothers' Home
4901 Eastern Avenue
Hyattsville, MD 20782
(301) 559-5500
For more information contact: Peggy Howard Gatewood,
Director
St. Ann's, a Catholic charity, has taken in pregnant women
since its inception in 1860. In 1983, it established a
program for adolescent mothers and their babies. Currently
14 young women, aged 16-19, and their babies live at the
home for up to two years. On average, 23 young women go
through the program annually. Many are referred from foster
care and other public agencies, while some are homeless and
come in off the street.
The cost is $175 daily for a mother and baby. Funding
is provided by a combination of state block grants, local
government appropriations, allocations from the United Way,
and private grants. For those who can afford it, payment is
based on sliding scale.
The mothers are supervised 24 hours a day by a staff of
27, including social workers, nurses, child care workers, a
parenting specialist, a job placement specialist, and a
child psychologist.
St. Elizabeth's Regional Maternity Center, Southern Indiana
621 E. Market Street
New Albany, IN 47150
(812) 949-7305
For more information contact: Joan Smith, Founder and
Director
Established in 1989, St. Elizabeth's consists of two homes:
a maternity home for pregnant teenage women and an aftercare
home for teen mothers and their babies. St. Elizabeth's is
funded by donations from private individuals and corporate
donors, community development block grants, HUD, the March
of Dimes, and HHS. In the past six years, 182 babies have
been born at St. Elizabeth's. There are no age restrictions,
although most of the mothers are aged 15-20. They are
referred from schools, doctors, hospitals, and word of
mouth.
The cost per mother and child is $80 a day in the
maternity home, and residents who are able pay the home on a
sliding scale. The aftercare home costs $4,800 per year per
mother and child, thanks to a $1.5 million grant from HUD
and a multitude of in-kind contributions from community
groups. While it depends heavily on volunteer support, St.
Elizabeth's has 14 full-time staffers, including three with
MSW degrees, and two part-time employees.
The home offers parenting and child care classes, self-
esteem classes, and counseling. One staff member is a sex
abuse therapist and provides individual counseling as well
as group sessions and family counseling.
T.A.M.I. (Teen-Age Mothers and Infants) House
509 Branard Road
Houston, TX 77006
(713) 527-0718
For more information contact: Barbara Reid, Executive
Director
The Teen-Age Mothers and Infants House is a traditional home
that houses up to six mothers with their babies. Residents
live in T.A.M.I. House for an average of 10-12 months, but
others are there anywhere from six-18 months. Mothers can be
16-17 1/2 years old when they enter the program. Funding
comes from the Child Protective Services, Community
Development Block Grants, the United Way, private donations,
and churches. The cost per resident is $15 a day for a baby
and $35 a day for a mother.
The staff consists of a single female house parent and
a nursery worker. In addition, pro bono therapists are hired
to council the residents. Volunteers are used only to
augment the professional staff, to help in the nursery, get
food at the food bank, or perform general office duties. The
program encourages residents to enrich their lives by
attending plays, visiting museums, and participating in
community events.
Teen Mothers Program/Sasha Bruce Youthwork
701 Maryland Avenue, N.E.
Washington, DC 20002
(202) 675-9380
For more information contact: Brenda Lockley, Director
The Teen Mothers Program is a residential treatment facility
for five teenage mothers and their babies run by the Sasha
Bruce Youthwork program, a private, nonprofit agency. The
Teen Mothers Program is funded directly by grants from the
DC Department of Human Services, Family Service Division. It
costs approximately $110 per day per person to run the
program. The participants are aged 15-18 and stay from 18
months to two years. The teen mothers are referred by the
court system and are wards of the DC government. All court-
remanded cases must be accepted into the home.
Residents are offered a number of classes in cooking,
child care, female health and sexuality, and living and
parenting skills. Counseling, tutoring, art therapy, and
referrals are also available.
There are no resident staff members; supervision is
provided by two staffers at a time based on rotating shifts.
Volunteers and foster grandparents are important elements of
the program.
The Teen Parent Residence
1750 Indian School Road, N.E.
Apartment 109
Albuquerque, NM 87104
(505) 246-2497
For more information contact: Barbara Calderon, Center
Director, Albuquerque Job Corps
The Teen Parent Residence is a referral-only home for 14
young mothers and their babies, aged 14-22. During the four
and a half years the program has been running, 117
participants have gone through the program. Professionals
provide counseling and training in health, nutrition,
parenting skills, independent living, family planning,
safety, child development, self-esteem building, and
necessary life skills such as budgeting and shopping.
Each teen and her baby receive AFDC, Food Stamps, WIC,
and Medicaid. Out of the AFDC money, the rent and utilities
are paid as well as other basic requirements. Child care is
provided by the Children, Youth, and Families Department
during the day to allow the mothers to attend school. The
program is maintained through state funding with community
organizations providing furniture for the apartments and
supplies for the project.
Kathleen Sylvester is the vice president of domestic policy
for the Progressive Policy Institute.
|